Valnow
Valuation methods

How to normalize net operating income for a valuation

The NOI on a borrower's operating statement is rarely the NOI a buyer would pay for. Normalizing it is the first step of a credible income approach.

Bar chart illustration of rising net operating income

Net operating income (NOI) is the income a property produces after operating expenses and before debt service and income taxes. For valuation, what matters is not last year's accounting result but the stabilized income a typical buyer would expect. Getting there is called normalizing the NOI.

The structure of an operating statement

LineWhat it contains
Potential gross income (PGI)Rent at 100% occupancy, plus other income such as parking, storage or reimbursements
− Vacancy and collection lossExpected loss from vacant space and unpaid rent
= Effective gross income (EGI)The income the property can be expected to collect
− Operating expensesTaxes, insurance, utilities, repairs and maintenance, management, and replacement reserves where that is the market practice
= Net operating income (NOI)The income available before debt service and income taxes

Step 1: use market rent where the leases do not

Look at each lease. Rents well above or below the market will roll to market at expiry. For a short-term lease, using market rent is often reasonable; for a long lease to a creditworthy tenant, the contract rent may be what a buyer pays for. Say which you used.

Step 2: apply a market vacancy

A building that happens to be 100% leased today still carries vacancy risk. Apply a vacancy and collection loss consistent with the market and the property's tenancy, even if the actual figure last year was zero. For single-tenant properties, consider the risk of the lease ending.

Step 3: remove what is not an operating expense

These items often appear on borrowers' statements but are not operating expenses:

  • mortgage principal and interest;
  • depreciation and amortization;
  • income taxes of the owner;
  • capital improvements, such as a new roof or HVAC system (consider a replacement reserve instead);
  • one-time costs such as a lawsuit, a leasing commission spike or a major repair after a storm;
  • owner's personal expenses run through the property.

Step 4: add what is missing

  • Management fee: an owner who manages the building personally may show no management cost. A buyer would pay one, typically a percentage of EGI.
  • Replacement reserves: include them if that is how buyers in the market underwrite this property type, and remember to treat the cap rate the same way.
  • Reassessed taxes: in some states a sale triggers a new tax assessment, which a buyer would expect.

Step 5: test against the market

Compare the normalized NOI per square foot, or per unit for multifamily, with the market. If it is far above the median for similar properties in the county, either the property is exceptional or something is missing from the expenses. If it is far below, there may be vacancy, below-market leases or excess costs.

Valnow compares the NOI you enter with the county's median NOI for the property type, based on actual transactions. A difference above 20% is noted in the review, and a difference above 50% asks you to confirm the figure; the confidence score reflects the difference. In an evaluation, both figures sit side by side in the income approach and the valuer chooses which to use.

Document every adjustment

A reviewer should be able to go from the borrower's statement to your NOI line by line. A short reconciliation table with each adjustment and its reason makes the income approach far easier to accept, and the result is ready to be capitalized with a supported cap rate.

This article is general information, not legal or regulatory advice. Check your institution's policies and your regulator's current guidance before applying it to a loan.