How to select and support a cap rate for a commercial evaluation
In the income approach, a quarter point of cap rate can move value by several percent. Here is how to choose a rate you can defend, and how to show your work.
The direct capitalization method values an income property in one step: value = net operating income ÷ capitalization rate. The NOI is usually the better-documented of the two inputs. The cap rate is where reviewers push back, because it is easy to pick one that produces the value you expected.
Why the rate matters so much
Take a property with an NOI of $250,000:
| Cap rate | Indicated value | Change vs. 7.50% |
|---|---|---|
| 7.00% | $3,571,000 | +7.1% |
| 7.50% | $3,333,000 | — |
| 8.00% | $3,125,000 | −6.3% |
| 8.50% | $2,941,000 | −11.8% |
Half a point of cap rate moves the value by more than 6%. Supporting the rate is therefore as important as supporting the income.
Step 1: extract rates from the market
The most direct support is market extraction: for recent sales of similar properties, divide each sale's NOI by its price. Use recorded sales with verified income, not asking prices or broker opinions. The more similar the sales are in type, location, age and tenancy, the better.
When you have several rates, look at the median as well as the average: a single unusual sale can pull an average far from the typical rate. Look at the spread too. Valnow reports, for the MSA and property type, the median and average cap rate of the last 12 months, and a low-to-high range of one standard deviation around the average, bounded by the rates actually observed.
Step 2: match the NOI basis
A market cap rate is only meaningful if the NOI it is applied to is measured the same way as the NOI of the sales it came from. Common mismatches:
- applying a rate derived from in-place NOI to a pro forma, stabilized NOI;
- including replacement reserves in the subject's expenses but not in the comparables';
- using a gross lease property's income against rates from net-leased sales without adjusting the expenses.
See how to normalize NOI for the subject's side of the equation.
Step 3: position the subject within the range
Once you have a market range, decide where the subject belongs, and say why. Factors that justify a lower rate (higher value) include a newer or better-located building, a long lease to a strong tenant, or low expense risk. Factors that justify a higher rate include short remaining lease terms, a single tenant with weak credit, deferred maintenance, or a weaker location within the MSA.
Step 4: check the trend
Rates move with interest rates and investor demand. A rate taken from sales over the last three years may already be out of date. Look at the yearly medians: if they have been rising, a rate from the middle of the period understates today's rate. Valnow shows three years of cap rate trends for the MSA and the state for this reason.
Step 5: cross-check
- Implied cap rate: divide the subject's NOI by the value from the sales comparison approach. If it falls far outside the market range, one of the two approaches needs another look.
- Band of investment: where financing terms are known, a mortgage-equity build-up can confirm the rate is consistent with what buyers can borrow at.
- Sensitivity: show the value at the low and high ends of the supported range so the reader sees the uncertainty.
In a Valnow Evaluation
The income approach in Valnow Evaluation starts from the market cap rate for the MSA and property type, shows the subject's NOI next to the county's median NOI, and recalculates the value as soon as you change the rate. The rate you choose, and your reasoning, go into the report.
This article is general information, not legal or regulatory advice. Check your institution's policies and your regulator's current guidance before applying it to a loan.