Valnow
Lending rules

The Interagency Appraisal and Evaluation Guidelines, in practice

Issued in December 2010, the Guidelines are still the reference examiners use to judge a bank's appraisal and evaluation program. This summary focuses on what matters for commercial evaluations.

Illustration of a checklist document

The Interagency Appraisal and Evaluation Guidelines were published in December 2010 by the federal banking agencies (the OCC, the Federal Reserve, the FDIC, the former OTS and the NCUA). They explain how institutions should run their real estate appraisal and evaluation programs, and they replaced the 1994 guidelines. In 2016, the agencies added an advisory on the use of evaluations, which answers common questions without changing the rules.

The Guidelines are long. Below are the parts that shape a commercial evaluation file.

1. An appraisal and evaluation program

The board and management are expected to adopt a program that fits the institution's size and lending. It should set out when an appraisal or an evaluation is used, how preparers are selected, what each report must contain, how reports are reviewed, and how collateral is monitored after the loan is made. Examiners start here: a good file in a bank without a written program still raises questions.

2. Independence

The people who order, prepare and review appraisals and evaluations should be independent of the loan production and collection process. A loan officer should not select the valuer or influence the value. Small institutions that cannot fully separate the functions are expected to put compensating controls in place, such as having a person outside the loan decision review the evaluation.

3. Selecting who prepares the evaluation

An evaluation does not have to be prepared by a licensed appraiser, but the preparer must have the training, experience and knowledge of the market for the property type. Institutions should document why each preparer is qualified. Using a state-licensed or certified appraiser for evaluations is common, but not required.

4. When evaluations are allowed

Evaluations are permitted for transactions exempt from the appraisal requirement: commercial real estate transactions of $500,000 or less since 2018, qualifying business loans of $1,000,000 or less, and certain renewals and refinancings. See our threshold guide.

5. Evaluation content

The Guidelines list what an evaluation should contain, at a minimum, to support the credit decision: the property's location and description, the market value conclusion with its effective date, the inspection method, the analysis and supporting information, the sources, and the preparer's name and contact information. We go through each item in what a commercial evaluation must contain.

6. Analytical methods and technological tools

Appendix B addresses evaluations that rely on tools such as automated valuation models and tax assessment values. The message is balanced: tools are acceptable, but the institution must:

  • establish that the tool is reliable for the property type and the market, through validation and periodic testing;
  • understand the data and the methodology behind it;
  • make sure the evaluation reflects the property's actual physical condition, which a model cannot observe on its own;
  • add supporting information when the tool's output alone is not enough.

This is why a model value works best as one approach and a cross-check inside an evaluation, not as the whole evaluation. Read more in how a commercial AVM values a property.

7. Validity of an existing evaluation

An existing appraisal or evaluation can support a new transaction if it remains valid. The institution should consider the passage of time, changes in the market, and changes in the property, and document why the earlier value still holds.

8. Review

Appraisals and evaluations should be reviewed before the credit decision, with a depth that matches the risk of the transaction. The reviewer checks that the report is complete, that the method suits the property, and that the conclusion is supported. Reviewers should also be independent and qualified.

9. Monitoring collateral

After the loan is made, the institution should monitor collateral values, especially in markets that move. Periodic automated valuations and market trend reports are a cost-effective way to see where a portfolio is exposed.

Using the Guidelines as a checklist

Valnow Evaluation is structured around the evaluation content the Guidelines describe, records every figure's source and date, keeps an audit trail of each action, and locks the report once the valuer signs. Your institution remains responsible for its program, its policies and its review.

This article is general information, not legal or regulatory advice. Check your institution's policies and your regulator's current guidance before applying it to a loan.