Valnow
Evaluations

What a commercial real estate evaluation must contain

An evaluation can be shorter than an appraisal, but not thinner. Use this checklist to make sure each report supports the credit decision on its own.

Illustration of commercial buildings

The Interagency Appraisal and Evaluation Guidelines say that an evaluation should contain sufficient information and analysis to support the decision to make the loan. They then list a minimum content. Here it is, item by item, with the questions an examiner or a reviewer is likely to ask.

1. The property's location

A complete address, and where useful the parcel number (APN) and legal description. Reviewer question: can someone else find exactly this property, and only this one?

2. A description of the property and its use

Property type and subtype, building size, site size, year built, condition, and the current and projected use. For income property, the tenancy and the lease structure. Reviewer question: does the description match the inspection, the photos and the public record?

3. An estimate of market value

The value of the property in its actual physical condition, use and zoning as of the effective date, with any limiting conditions stated. Reviewer question: is it clearly market value, and not an investment value, a list price or a value "upon completion" presented as current?

4. How the physical condition was confirmed

The method used to confirm the property's actual condition, and the extent of the inspection: interior and exterior, exterior only, or a review of recent photos and documents. Reviewer question: is the inspection proportionate to the risk, and are its limits disclosed?

5. The analysis and supporting information

The approach or approaches used, and the data that support them. For commercial property, that usually means a sales comparison approach with adjusted comparables, an income approach when the property produces or could produce rent, and a cost approach where it is relevant. Reviewer question: does the method suit the property, and could another valuer reproduce the conclusion from the file?

6. Supplemental information for analytical tools

When an automated valuation model or another tool is used, the evaluation should include the information that the tool cannot provide, starting with the property's physical condition, and should show that the tool is appropriate for the property and the market. Reviewer question: is the model one input among several, or is it doing all the work?

7. The sources of information

Every data source: sales databases, public records, market reports, the borrower's operating statements, inspection notes. Reviewer question: can each key figure be traced to where it came from?

8. The effective date

The date as of which the value applies, distinct from the date of the report. Reviewer question: is the effective date recent enough for the transaction and the market?

9. The preparer

The name and contact information of the person who prepared the evaluation, and their signature. Reviewer question: is this person qualified for the property type and independent of the loan?

Beyond the minimum

Strong evaluation files usually also contain:

  • a market overview with value, NOI and cap rate trends for the MSA;
  • a reconciliation that explains the weight given to each approach (see our reconciliation guide);
  • flood zone and zoning information;
  • maps, aerial and street-level views, and inspection photos;
  • stated assumptions, limiting conditions and restrictions of use.

How Valnow handles each item

Valnow Evaluation prepares each section from data, marks in yellow what the valuer must still provide, links every figure to its source and date, and will not let the report be generated or signed until each section is complete or marked not applicable. The effective date, preparer and signature are part of the report, and the signed version is locked.

This article is general information, not legal or regulatory advice. Check your institution's policies and your regulator's current guidance before applying it to a loan.